Chaffetz: Sell Y Mountain land to BYU
By Donald W. Meyers
The Salt Lake TribuneFirst published May 06 2012 06:14PM
U.S. Rep Jason Chaffetz wants Brigham Young University to own the federal land on which its iconic block Y sits.
Chaffetz, R-Utah and a former BYU football kicker, recently introduced HR4484, which would require the U.S. Forest Service sell 80 acres of land on Y Mountain to BYU.
The university, which requested the legislation, has the resources to better maintain the trail leading up to the 106-year-old landmark, Chaffetz said. His bill would require the forest service to sell the land to BYU at fair market value.
"There have been complaints about access, water on the trail and cleanliness," Chaffetz said.
Sen. Orrin Hatch, R-Utah, introduced similar legislation in the Senate.
Loyal Clark, Uinta-Wasatch-Cache National Forest spokeswoman, said the forest service is still reviewing the Chaffetz proposal.
And a BYU spokesman said a change in ownership will not restrict access to the Y, a popular hiking destination.
"Nothing will change for the public," said Todd Hollingshead. "They will still be able to access it as in the past."
Chaffetz said BYU owns the lower half of the Y trail going up to the mountain, but the Y and the upper half of the trail are on forest service property.
Clark said the forest service issues BYU a special-use permit allowing it to maintain the Y.
Chaffetz said there have been some problems with litter on the trail, as well as a lack of water for hikers. He said the last time he hiked the trail he saw garbage, but said it was an overall positive experience.
He said BYU would have more resources for maintaining the trail than the forest service, which he said is stretched thin.
Clark said the forest service uses volunteers to help maintain trails on forest service land.
Chaffetz’s bill is co-sponsored by Reps. Eni Faleomavaega, D-American Samoa; Jeff Flake, R-Arizona; and Howard "Buck" McKeon, R-Calif. All three are BYU alumni.
Hatch’s bill is co-sponsored by Sen. Mike Lee, R-Utah, and son of former BYU President Rex E. Lee.
Salt Lake civil rights attorney Brian Barnard saw no constitutional problem with selling the forest service land to BYU, which is owned by The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
"But such displays are rather ugly," Barnard said in an email. "Perhaps the federal government might sell 80 acres to Nu Skin [Enterprises]."